10 fast food menu items that were quietly discontinued despite being massive hits
Fast food chains pull items for reasons that have nothing to do with popularity. Supply chain costs, operational complexity, menu streamlining and corporate strategy all outweigh customer loyalty when a spreadsheet makes the call. The result is a graveyard of beloved menu items that vanished while their fans were still ordering them.
The appetite for these items did not disappear when the items did.
1. McDonald’s McRib
Introduced in 1981, the McRib was pulled from permanent U.S. menus in 2005 and has survived ever since through limited seasonal returns that generate genuine media coverage every time. Time Out reports it generates over 327,000 Google searches per year, more than double the next most-searched discontinued item. It remains a permanent fixture in Germany and Luxembourg.
2. Taco Bell Mexican Pizza
On the menu since 1985, it quietly pulled in 2020 to simplify pandemic-era operations. Time Out reports that a Change.org petition gathered over 200,000 signatures demanding its return. In 2022, the chain brought it back permanently, making it one of the most successful fan-driven menu reversals in fast food history.
3. KFC Double Down
Two pieces of fried chicken as the bun. Yahoo Finance confirms 10 million were ordered in its first few months. It has returned for limited runs multiple times. Customers keep showing up.
4. Chipotle Carne Asada
Launched in 2019, gone by 2020. Cheapism reports 132,680 annual Google searches, the second highest of any discontinued fast food item. Chipotle has brought it back for limited runs and recently brought it back permanently.
5. Taco Bell Enchirito
An enchilada-burrito hybrid that traces to 1970. Discontinued in 1993, revived in 2000, pulled in 2013, briefly returned after a fan vote in November 2022, gone again since. The cycle has been running for over five decades.
6. KFC Potato Wedges
Replaced by standard fries in 2020. Around 54,000 people search for them annually. This fast-food fave is back on the menu!
7. Burger King Chicken Fries
Launched in 2005, discontinued in 2012. Dedicated fan accounts campaigned for its return. It came back in 2015 and has stayed.
8. Domino’s Brooklyn Style Pizza
Domino’s launched a thin-crust, wide-slice pizza designed to fold like an authentic New York slice in 2006. It stayed on the menu for 18 years before being discontinued in 2024 to make room for a new New York-style pizza. The irony of replacing a beloved pizza with a conceptually similar pizza was not lost on fans.
9. Taco Bell Meximelt
A seasoned beef taco wrapped in a soft tortilla with melted cheese and pico de gallo, introduced in 1988 and discontinued in 2019. Spin Genie recorded 70,000 annual searches for the Meximelt. A brief 2024 Southern California nostalgia revival drew long lines.
10. McDonald’s Szechuan sauce
Released in 1998 to promote Disney’s Mulan, forgotten for two decades, then revived by a Rick and Morty episode in 2017. When McDonald’s briefly brought it back that year, restaurants ran out within hours.
The bottom line
Every item on this list generated enough customer loyalty to outlast its removal by years. Petitions, social media campaigns, dedicated fan accounts and search volumes in the hundreds of thousands. The appetite for these products did not disappear when the products did. The chains know this, which is why so many of them keep returning as limited-time offers. It turns out that “discontinued” is often just another word for withheld.
Ask us! What questions do you have about content, strategy, pop culture, lifestyle, wellness, history or more? We may use your question in an upcoming article!
Related:
- Gone but not forgotten: Photos of classic mall stores we miss
- Gone but not forgotten: Photos of childhood snacks we miss
Like MediaFeed’s content? Be sure to follow us.
This article was syndicated by MediaFeed.co.
